6 Kitchen Features People Regret the Most, According to Designers

Designing your kitchen is a challenging process that can lead to costly mistakes, inefficient layouts, trendy finishes that date quickly, and extra fixtures that end up collecting dust. Here are the kitchen features that designers say people most often regret, with advice about what to choose instead.

Trend-Driven Finishes

Embracing the latest kitchen trends can be a recipe for regret.

“Sleek, high-gloss cabinetry or bold floor tiles might look amazing for a season,” Brophy advises. “But before long, they can feel cold or dated. Go for materials with warmth and soul like wood, plaster, natural stone. Pieces that age beautifully and don’t tie you to a moment in time.”

Want more design inspiration? Sign up for our free daily newsletter for the latest decor ideas, designer tips, and more!

Oversized Islands

Kitchen islands are a common wish list item that can overwhelm your space if the scale is out of proportion.

“The ‘bigger is better’ island sounds great in theory but often is a regret,” Brophy cautions. “When it’s oversized, it’s awkward to move around, tough to clean, and takes away from the flow of the kitchen. A right-sized island balances the room.”

If you need more surface area for meal prep or dining, or are designing a particularly large space, consider adding two kitchen islands, Brophy suggests.

Non-Essential Gadgets

Luxurious-seeming features like warming drawers, built-in coffee stations, soda taps, and other non-essential gadgets can end up being a waste of time and money,” Brophy warns.

“They sound great on paper but most of the time they go unused,” she says. “Invest in the workhorses you’ll love every single day. A great range, refrigeration, maybe even a second dishwasher. It’s the simple upgrades that really change how you live.”

Open Shelving

Install open shelving sparingly, advises interior designer Rebekah Murphy.

“Open shelving photographs beautifully and can feel light and airy at first,” she says. “But in reality, day-to-day living means dust, grease, and clutter quickly collect, and most clients tire of the constant styling and upkeep required to keep shelves looking curated.”

Busy Backsplashes

Beware of busy backsplashes, Murphy advises.

“Highly patterned or brightly colored backsplashes may feel exciting during installation,” she says, “but they tend to overwhelm the kitchen and date much faster than expected. Many clients later wish they had chosen something more restrained that would allow the cabinetry and architecture to
shine.”

Try a timeless stone slab backsplash to bring “depth, elegance, and subtle movement without competing for attention” and inject personality into your kitchen by layering it with an evolving selection of art, lighting, or bar stools, Murphy suggests.

Same-Color Finishes

“Choosing the same finish for cabinetry, counters, and backsplash may seem sleek and cohesive at first,” Murphy says, “but many clients later regret how flat and unforgiving it feels.”

All-white kitchens are the most common example of this, the designer says. “Every fingerprint and spill shows instantly, and the uniformity can read sterile rather than welcoming.” She suggests introducing subtle contrast through soft neutrals, natural woods, or stone with veining and character for a livable feel.